See this is why I still say Steve Nash is better than CP3!!!

He just has much better court vision it's not even close and Steve Nash has the best offensively sound game along with CB1 than all the other PG's in the NBA. If Nash is playing under this system that he has played for his entire career before starting last season with more of a half-court set styled offense he would relish instead of struggle, like in the beginning of last season.

CP3 is a better defender, but he has yet to show that he is a leader he's been upstagged in the playoffs by Billups and Parker and Williams has gotten the best of him throughout their careers. CP3 is also in a system that suites his needs if you put CP3 in Utah and Williams in NO. I think both players are great enough to make them contend for a playoff spot, but Paul would struggle like Nash did under Porter on a Sloan styled team. That's just not his game.

However, when it comes to intangibles and achievements Nash has 4 WCF appearances and just is more versatile as a PG IMO.

I disagree, Cp3 > nash now.


1. Williams


2. parker

3. paul

4.billups

5.nash

1. Billups
2. Williams
3. Parker
4. Nash
5. Paul

But, we can agree to disagree!!!It's good to argue once in awhile.

It's arguable whos better paul or nash, but some people say paul is #1 which is retarded! Parker and williams are easily better than CP3

Well, I think CP3 is better for two reasons

1. he actualy plays defense, although he's nothing special at it
2. he doesn't need to be in a certain system to suceed like Nash does

I say yes they are Parker is extremely underrated and Williams to me is going to be the best PG in the NBA for many years to come.

Individually, I think CP3 is better than Nash right now.
His game is much more complete - he can rebound, score, and even averaged more assists than Nash last season.
Nash is still very good but he is getting a bit older and Paul is just getting better and better as a player and as a leader. Nash has the upper hand when it comes to leadership (e.g. two MVP honours consecutively) but Paul, I see, will emerge as a leader.

He makes his teammates better and without his presence, the Hornets would not go as far (especially with that craptacular bench...). Therefore, I feel Paul is the better player at this moment.

Paul is better now,but if Nash played his hall career on this system.Every PG besides Kidd would be a laugh for Nash game