Kareem Abdul Jabbar or Earvin 'Magic' Johnson

Who is the better player,who acomplished more,who is more skilled,who did more wtihout the other and etc

My vote goes to Jabbar

Better player is Magic, Accomplished is Kareem (if that counted, wouldn't Russell and Chamberlain be the GOAT's??), Skilled is... Kareem

Kareem but someone needs to lock this post

Darko wrote:

Kareem but someone needs to lock this post

Why lock it?


Kareem > magic. Id take a dominant bigman o ver a dominant PG ANYDAY

IMO Magic...Kareem never won a Championship with the Lakers until Magic was signed. Magic lead them to a Championship his first year. was injured in his second year and took them back to the Championship his third year. Magic had the skill and ability to play all 5 positions, and did when called upon.
1979/80 The Lakers compiled a 60–22 record in the regular season and reached the 1980 NBA Finals,[22] in which they faced the Philadelphia 76ers, who were led by forward Julius Erving. The Lakers took a 3–2 lead in the series, but Abdul-Jabbar, who averaged 33 points a game in the series,[23] sprained his ankle in Game 5 and could not play in Game 6.[20] Paul Westhead decided to start Johnson at center in Game 6; Johnson recorded 42 points, 15 rebounds, seven assists, and three steals in a 123–107 win, while playing guard, forward, and center at different times during the game.[20] Johnson became the only rookie to win the NBA Finals MVP award.
1981/82 joined Wilt Chamberlain and Oscar Robertson as the only NBA players to tally at least 700 points, 700 rebounds, and 700 assists in the same season
Magic played 13 seasons (1979–1991, 1996)
Kareem was strictly an inside player, No way Kareem could play PG, He didn't handle the ball well enough. Kareem played for 20 years 1969 to 1989 to accumulate career stats, 7 years longer then the average all star.
Although I admired Kareem and believe he is one of the best ever to play the game, in my opinion Magic is the GOAT

Kareem>Magic,he's more skilled and acomplished more by far.What again has Magic done since Jabbar retire?

It's very easly to tell which is better,just compare their acomplishments before they play together and you have it

Darko wrote:

Kareem>Magic,he's more skilled and acomplished more by far.What again has Magic done since Jabbar retire?

Magic led the Lakers to the finals in his second(?) season without Jabbar...

Jabbar didn't do shit while o the Lakers when Magic was hurt or gone

Cavs Browns Indians wrote:

Darko wrote:

Kareem>Magic,he's more skilled and acomplished more by far.What again has Magic done since Jabbar retire?

Magic led the Lakers to the finals in his second(?) season without Jabbar...

Jabbar didn't do shit while o the Lakers when Magic was hurt or gone

What about his sucess in the Buks,yeap playing in a creappy teams once again overlooks your sucess

Kareem won one championship on the Bucks and his team sure as hell wasn't crappy.

He had mother fuckign Oscar Robertson on his team.
Let's see him win an NBA championship without THe Big O or Magic.

Cavs Browns Indians wrote:

Kareem won one championship on the Bucks and his team sure as hell wasn't crappy.

He had mother fuckign Oscar Robertson on his team.
Let's see him win an NBA championship without THe Big O or Magic.

Oscar Roberston was in his latest stage of his career,so he was really,realy old but Kareem manege to beat everyone with his clutch sky hoop to get the win.What again Magic did without Kareem,nothing...

My vote go for Magic Johnson cause he is my favourite player in the NBA All Time and he is the 3rd NBA All Time player.

i am heat fan wrote:

My vote go for Magic Johnson cause he is my favourite player in the NBA All Time and he is the 3rd NBA All Time player.

Hi,Stevo.When did the hell Magic become your fave player,Kareem is better