I personally say Scottie Reynolds. I think he can be a decent backup PG in the NBA and was a great leader, clutch player, solid shooter,and teammate in college. I'm stunned that an All-American like him didn't at least get Drafted Round 2.
Secondly I'd take Saint Mary's big man Omar Samhan. I thought he had 1st Round potential after seeing him in College but he didn't even get Drafted. I'd be happy to go after him