All Time Draft Game Semifinals: Knicks vs Spurs

Spurs

Why?

The knicks eliminated me.......

Knicks. Starting lineup domination. Spurs have no answer for Melo+Billups off the bench, Gasol has too much length for Webber.

Knicks win and win easy. It would be ugly too.

Spurs!

Spurs.

I find Wilt to be quite overrated. David Robinson will easily hold his own against him IMO.
TD should dominate Dennis Rodman.

Magic is the only thing Knicks' starting lineup has over the Spurs.
ok maybe West too. But not by a lot.

Bench is better for the Knicks though.

But Spurs for me.

YS wrote:

Spurs.

I find Wilt to be quite overrated. David Robinson will easily hold his own against him IMO.
TD should dominate Dennis Rodman.

Magic is the only thing Knicks' starting lineup has over the Spurs.
ok maybe West too. But not by a lot.

Bench is better for the Knicks though.

But Spurs for me.

Bill Russell and Kareem couldn't stop Wilt, how is a wimp like Robinson gonna stop Wilt?

I never said he would stop Wilt.

All I said was....he isn't gonna dominate and score 50 pts.....
Like many people think Wilt will do every single game...

YS wrote:

I never said he would stop Wilt.

All I said was....he isn't gonna dominate and score 50 pts.....
Like many people think Wilt will do every single game...

I agree. Wilt wouldn't score 50 a game (low 30's yeah)... but in a playoff series versus Robinson?

David would not kill Goliath.

Robinson would be more effected by Wilt than the other way around. And he would dominate Robinson inside.

Knicks bench is a playoff team, just throw in a center and a 2 guard.. The other bench is a group of okay players. Alex English over Wilkins?

Knicks win this. Sorry SRF.

lol. The only matchup Spurs have over the Knicks is PF, and it's not even by that much, Dennis was a DPOY beasttt. Wilt doesnt have to score 50, Knicks have other offensive threats like, West, Wilkins, Magic, Melo. He'd eat Robinson for lunch on both sides of the ball.

I agree with YS a little. Wilt wouldn't come close to dominating Robinson, or even Duncan. Shaq always struggled vs that front court. So would Wilt. There's mismatches going both ways though. Jaleesa's shooting guard has a huge size/athleticism advantage over West and Jaleesa doesn't have the personnel to effectively stop Magic. I actually like Jaleesa's bench better because they all bring more than scoring. Webber was an effective rebounder and passer, Jones a solid defender and Houston a premier shooter. Still unsure of who to vote for.

I'll go with Abdi, though, even though his bench isn't that great. Magic is just unguardable by Kevin Johnson and if they put Gervin on him West would no longer have a mismatch.

Knicks.

I'm the Knicks.

FIXED

Shaq and Wilt had completely different games.

Wilt had a jumper, was an good passer and had far more post moves than Shaq. Shaq always tried to power himself into Robinson or take his weak hook shot. You can't compare Shaq and Wilt other than size and weight and FT%.

Spurs.

Breathe wrote:

Spurs

Why?

The knicks eliminated me.......

Knicks

Why?

The Spurs eliminated me........

Spurs,

Knicks..very easily

Know what I hate?
When ppl vote for the other team just cuz a team eliminated you.


It just makes ur team look bad if the team that beat you gets blown out the next round.
Gosh


Knicks

Niks

Nick C wrote:

YS wrote:

I never said he would stop Wilt.

All I said was....he isn't gonna dominate and score 50 pts.....
Like many people think Wilt will do every single game...

I agree. Wilt wouldn't score 50 a game (low 30's yeah)... but in a playoff series versus Robinson?

David would not kill Goliath.

Robinson would be more effected by Wilt than the other way around. And he would dominate Robinson inside.

Knicks bench is a playoff team, just throw in a center and a 2 guard.. The other bench is a group of okay players. Alex English over Wilkins?

Knicks win this. Sorry SRF.

Damn Nick; has Abdi hired you to sway the votes in his favour?

LOL...totally kidding. No need to apologize, haha.

Knicks...sorry, SRF...

Nick is da bomb. Jay Jay you know I ain't gotta pay anyone, people Volunteer. And how is this not a sweep? jk.

lol abdi...and hush about the sweep :p

sweet, at least I made it to the semis...better than last time